Animal Legal Defense Fund Suit Against Foie Gras Seller Dismissed After Court of Appeal Victory
Restaurant Vows to Cease Foie Gras “Giveaways” Declared Illegal by Appellate Court
SAN FRANCISCO – Today, a long-running lawsuit against Napa restaurant La Toque concluded, with the restaurant promising in court filings to never again sell foie gras in violation of a statewide ban on the sale of this cruelly-produced “gourmet” delicacy. Foie gras is made by force-feeding ducks and geese massive quantities of grain, then slaughtering them for their diseased, enlarged livers.
La Toque’s vow to cease foie gras sales came in response to a lawsuit filed by the Animal Legal Defense Fund, the nation’s preeminent legal advocacy organization for animals. The court dismissed the case after finding that the California Court of Appeal had already deemed the conduct uncovered by the Animal Legal Defense Fund at La Toque to be a violation of the law, leaving nothing left for it to resolve. Through undercover investigations, the Animal Legal Defense Fund demonstrated La Toque was violating California law by serving foie gras as a “gift” accompanying an expensive tasting menu, a ploy the Court of Appeal found unlawful in a precedent-setting decision issued in 2015.
While the case against La Toque has concluded, this is not the end of the Animal Legal Defense Fund’s commitment to ensuring California law is followed. The organization continues to pursue enforcement against any restaurant or seller violating the foie gras ban.
“Ducks and geese suffer immensely to produce foie gras. That’s why California prohibits the production and sale of this abusive product,” says Animal Legal Defense Fund Executive Director Stephen Wells. “Thanks to our lawsuit, La Toque vowed to cease illegal foie gras sales — and we will continue to hold accountable any other seller that flouts the law.”
California’s ban, which went into effect in 2012, was spurred by evidence of force-fed ducks in Sonoma, California, who were fattened so inhumanely they could not escape being eaten alive by rats in dark, filthy pens.
The California law faced a seven-year legal challenge by foie gras producers and sellers, in which the Animal Legal Defense Fund and fellow animal advocacy groups frequently filed briefs in defense of the landmark humane measure. In September 2017, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the constitutionality of the foie gras ban, and the U.S. Supreme Court denied the industry’s petition to review that holding in early 2019.
Anyone who sees foie gras in California restaurants or stores should report the illegal sale to the police, and submit details to the Animal Legal Defense Fund via this online tip portal: aldf.org/reportfoiegras.
For more information, visit aldf.org.
The U.S. District Court for the Central District of California dismissed the industry’s constitutional challenge in its entirety, and forbade the plaintiffs from trying to renew those claims.January 15, 2020 News
The Animal Legal Defense Fund applauds Speaker Corey Johnson and the NYC Council for voting to end the sale of foie gras. Intro 1378, sponsored by Council Member Carlina Rivera, now moves to Mayor de Blasio, who is expected to sign the bill into law.October 30, 2019 News
Advocates for animals, free speech and the environment take on secrecy at factory farms following victories in Utah, Idaho, Wyoming and IowaJune 25, 2019 Press Release