Episode 6: Crimes on Behalf of Animals
Animal Amicus podcast
When are actions on behalf of an animal illegal? What are some valid defenses to crimes committed on behalf of an animal? When is a crime excused? Nicole Pallotta and David Rosengard tackle these and other questions as they discuss the bearing witness movement, constitutional issues that can come up when advocates clash with the industry, “Good Samaritan” laws, ag-gag laws, and open rescues.
Listen to Episode 6:
Resources
Resources referenced in this episode along with additional relevant articles are listed below:
- NPR: Animal Rights Activist on Trial in Canada for Giving Water to Pigs
- Animal Studies Journal: Bodily Encounter, Bearing Witness and the Engaged Activism of the Global Save Movement by Alex Lockwood
- USDA National Agricultural Library: Twenty-Eight Hour Law
- Animal Legal Defense Fund: Defending Animal Activists’ First Amendment Rights
- Animal Legal Defense Fund: Animal Advocates Win Free Speech Case, Judge Dismisses Meritless Trespassing Suit Intended to Silence Critics
- Reporters Committee: Understanding Anti-SLAPP Laws
- Animal Legal & Historical Center: Maps of States that Have to Protect Animals in Parked Cars
- Animal Legal Defense Fund: Oregon Becomes 11th State to Pass “Good Samaritan Law” to Protect Dogs Left in Hot Cars by Nicole Pallotta
- Medium: Yes, I Broke into a Mercedes with My Car Jack by Shawna Harch
- GOV.UK: Pet Abduction to be Made New Criminal Offence in Crackdown on Pet Theft
- Time: Lady Gaga Got Her Dogs Back, but as Criminals Capitalize on the Demand for Pandemic Pups, Others Aren’t So Lucky by Melissa Chan
- Office of the Governor Doug Ducey: Governor Ducey Signs “Matthew’s Law” to Protect Pets, Families
- Animal Legal Defense Fund: Ag-Gag Laws
- Seattle University Law Review: Ag Gag Past, Present, and Future by Justin F. Marceau
- First Amendment Watch: Ag-Gag Laws Face the First Amendment
- USDA Economic Research Service: Market Failures: When the Invisible Hand Gets Shaky
- Animal Legal Defense Fund: Challenging Judy’s Family Farm Organic Eggs’ Deceptive Advertising
- Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act
- Center for Constitutional Rights: The Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act (AETA)
- FindLaw: United States v. Fullmer, 584 F.3d 132, 164 (3d Cir. 2009)
- Case Western Reserve Law Review: United States v. Fullmer and the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act: “True Threats” to Advocacy
- The Intercept: How the Prosecution of Animal Rights Activists as Terrorists Foretold Today’s Criminalization of Dissent by Natasha Lennard
- MSU Journal of Animal & Natural Resource Law: Justifying Force Against Animal Cruelty by Ross Campbell
- Spolin Law: Can “Defense of Others” Apply in Animal Abuse Cases
- The Dodo: Open Rescue: How UPC Introduced This Strategy to U.S. Activists by Karen Davis
- Unbound Project: Fierce and Fearless: Patty Mark’s Unique Approach to Animal Liberation by Keri Cronin
- United Poultry Concerns: Terrorists or Freedom Fighters? Reflections on the Liberation of Animals
Meet the hosts
Learn more about the Animal Legal Defense Fund team.
-
Nicole Pallotta
Senior Policy Program Manager -
David B. Rosengard
Managing Attorney
Focus Area
How We Work
Related
-
RICO Lawsuit Filed Against Puppy Mill Broker JAKS Puppies and Its Ring of Associates
Class-action lawsuit alleges thousands in California purchased dogs under the false belief they were rescue animalsDecember 16, 2021 Press Release -
Animal Advocates Sue Pet Store and Phony Rescue Operation for Illegal Puppy Laundering Scheme
Today the Animal Legal Defense Fund filed a lawsuit against the Animal Kingdom pet store and purported rescue group Bark Adoptions for engaging in a puppy laundering scheme to unlawfully circumvent the California law that bans the sale of dogs.March 5, 2019 Press Release -
Lawsuit Moves Forward Against Pet Store and Phony Rescue Operations for Illegal Puppy Laundering Scheme
Animal Kingdom, Bark Adoptions, and Rescue Pets Iowa stand accused of selling puppy mill dogs in violation of California lawSeptember 3, 2019 Press Release