Defending an Individual’s Right to Protect Her Dog

The Animal Legal Defense Fund filed a lawsuit against a West Virginia State Police trooper for violating Tiffanie Hupp’s civil rights and breaking West Virginia law by nearly shooting a tied-up dog, and then arresting Hupp for saving the dog.


July 8, 2020

Work Type




Next Step

Update: The police department will pay $150,000 as part of the agreement. Read more in the press release.

In May 2015, West Virginia State Trooper Seth Cook walked onto a property in Waverly, West Virginia, where Buddy the dog was tied on a tether. Buddy wagged his tail.

Captured on video, Cook approached, drew his loaded gun, and pointed it at Buddy’s head. At the time, plaintiff Tiffanie Hupp was playing with her 3-year-old son Riley nearby. Cook directed those present to ‘control’ the dog. So Hupp swiftly moved toward Buddy and the gun-wielding state trooper, in an effort to save Buddy and to spare her son the trauma of seeing his beloved dog shot.

Cook grabbed Hupp, threw her down, pushed her against the police car, and arrested her. Cook then entered another plaintiff’s home—without warrant or consent—and confiscated the cell phone that had recorded Cook’s behavior. As a result of Cook’s actions, the state prosecuted Hupp for misdemeanor obstruction. A jury viewed the cell phone video however, and acquitted her in 2016.

In January 2017, the Animal Legal Defense Fund filed a federal lawsuit against Cook and Colonel C.R. “Jay” Smithers—then-superintendent of the West Virginia State Police. The lawsuit alleges that Cook violated the plaintiffs‘ constitutional rights and West Virginia law.

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia dismissed the case on summary judgment. The plaintiffs have appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Donate to Protect Animals

Help animals win the legal protections they so desperately need and deserve, and ensure they have an advocate in courtrooms and legislatures across the country.

Take Action Now




Recent News

Related Cases

Looking for case and legal resources? View Resources

See More

You Can Protect Animals

Since 1979, the Animal Legal Defense Fund has led the charge to win animals the legal protection they so desperately need—and deserve. Your generous gift will assure that we can continue to take on cases that advance the interests of animals.