Demanding USDA Revoke Animal Welfare Act License from Pennsylvania Roadside Zoo Claws ‘N’ Paws
Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Claws ‘N’ Paws
The Animal Legal Defense Fund filed a complaint urging the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to investigate and enforce the Animal Welfare Act (AWA) and its implementing regulations to decline to re-issue the exhibitor license of Pennsylvania roadside zoo, Claws ‘N’ Paws, which expires in May 2022.
USDA to Respond to Complaint
On May 3, 2022, the Animal Legal Defense Fund filed a complaint urging the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to investigate and enforce the Animal Welfare Act (AWA) and its implementing regulations to decline to re-issue the exhibitor license of Pennsylvania roadside zoo, Claws ‘N’ Paws, which expires in May 2022. Claws ‘N’ Paws exhibits and houses over 150 animals, listing over 55 species on its website. A first-person account of the suffering these animals endure at Claws ‘N’ Paws — supported by online testimonials, complaints to USDA, and USDA’s own inspection reports — highlights the need for USDA to comprehensively review the facility to determine whether it meets the minimum requirements of the AWA.
Upon visiting the facility in August 2021, an Animal Legal Defense Fund member from Pennsylvania saw animals suffering first-hand. She observed alarming conditions of the animals there. Big Cats, including cougars and lions, panted and paced in small enclosures. A cougar was unsteady and barely able to jump up on a small structure, while a black panther languished with his tongue hanging out of his mouth the entire length of the member’s visit, despite that day’s moderate temperature. A skinny fox alone in a small cage had a tiny den for shelter. The facility produced foul odors in multiple areas, which may indicate poor sanitation.
USDA inspection reports of the facility and online reviews and complaints confirm the inadequate conditions Animal Legal Defense Fund’s member observed. Violations include animals exhibiting psychological distress displayed through stereotypic behaviors, such as pacing and head bobbing. A TripAdvisor review notes, “[m]any animals were in enclosures that were not suited to the species, and which provided little if any shelter from the elements.” In a complaint to the USDA, one individual noted, “[w]e cried while we were there and cried when we left, the conditions were disgusting, filthy, and stinky.” A USDA routine inspection report from 2016 mentioned there had been “pooling water and feces in camel enclosure” all while the facilities’ license has continually been renewed by the USDA.
The Animal Legal Defense Fund uses all legal tools at its disposal to secure more and better protections for animals at roadside zoos and facilities exhibiting animals. The Animal Legal Defense Fund has lawsuits alleging violations of the Endangered Species Act and/or state animal cruelty laws pending against Pymatuning Deer Park in Jamestown, Pennsylvania and Farmers Inn roadside zoo in Sigel, Pennsylvania.
What action has been taken and related to what law? The complaint is sent to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to investigate and enforce the Animal Welfare Act (AWA) against licensee Claws ‘N’ Paws.
Why this case is important: Millions of wild animals are living in captivity across the U.S. Many of these animals are forced to live in aquariums, circuses, theme parks, and zoos, while others live caged in private homes. But few federal laws protect these animals, who may be forced to perform or who are kept confined in small cages with little to meet their complex social and behavioral needs, which makes it critical that current laws be enforced. The Animal Legal Defense Fund monitors roadside zoos and attractions across the U.S. to protect animals in facilities that do not meet the minimal standards required by the Animal Welfare Act and the Endangered Species Act.