The Animal Legal Defense Fund Sues USDA to Label Foie Gras for What It Is—Diseased
Suit asserts agency is misleading consumers with its seal of inspection
San Francisco. CA — The Animal Legal Defense Fund, the nation’s leading legal advocacy organization for animals, today filed suit against the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) for its “undue delay” in responding to an Animal Legal Defense Fund petition to require the labeling of foie gras.
In September 2011, Animal Legal Defense Fund filed a legal petition with the USDA and its Food Safety and Inspection Service urging that the agencies require that foie gras—the “fatty liver” of a force-fed duck or goose—bear a consumer warning label stating, “NOTICE: Foie gras products are derived from diseased birds.”
The Administrative Procedure Act requires agencies to conclude matters before them—including citizen petitions for rulemaking—within a reasonable time. Thus, by failing to respond to Animal Legal Defense Fund’s petition for more than four years, the USDA has violated the law. Animal Legal Defense Fund is asking the court to order the agency to answer its petition.
Foie gras consists of the pathologically diseased livers of ducks and geese, who are force-fed massive amounts of grain, which causes their livers to swell to ten times their normal size and induces numerous painful conditions in the birds.
“The USDA is responsible for ensuring that all poultry products that enter the food supply are from healthy animals,” said Stephen Wells, executive director of Animal Legal Defense Fund. “Despite the diseased origins of foie gras and the threat it poses to human health, the agency allows foie gras products to carry its official mark of inspection, which misleads consumers into thinking that they have been inspected for wholesomeness. This violates the Poultry Products Inspection Act.”
Animal Legal Defense Fund and a coalition of animal protection groups are concurrently suing the USDA for its denial of an earlier petition for rulemaking that asked the agency to keep this diseased poultry product out of the food supply as required by the Act.
The U.S. District Court for the Central District of California dismissed the industry’s constitutional challenge in its entirety, and forbade the plaintiffs from trying to renew those claims.January 15, 2020 News
The Animal Legal Defense Fund applauds Speaker Corey Johnson and the NYC Council for voting to end the sale of foie gras. Intro 1378, sponsored by Council Member Carlina Rivera, now moves to Mayor de Blasio, who is expected to sign the bill into law.October 30, 2019 News
In early 2017, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) purged tens of thousands of important documents related to animal welfare from the agency’s website. The purged inspection reports documented violations of the federal Animal Welfare Act (AWA).September 18, 2019 News