Challenging the USDA for Reissuing Roadside Zoo’s License
Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Thomas J. Vilsack
The Animal Legal Defense Fund sued the USDA in federal court for reissuing an Iowa roadside zoo license despite frequent violations recorded by the USDA’s own inspectors, including inadequate staffing, filthy enclosures, and deficient veterinary care.
Next Step
Case Closed
Life was not good for the animals at the Cricket Hollow Animal Park — formerly known as the Cricket Hollow Zoo — in Manchester, Iowa. Five tigers died in the span of two years, due to inadequate veterinary care. Another tiger was found to be suffering from open wounds, and hadn’t been treated by a veterinarian. A capuchin monkey, denied veterinary care, lost her hair and was seen chewing her tail from boredom and frustration. At least five lemurs also died.
Over the course of several years, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) documented a horrifying list of federal Animal Welfare Act violations at Cricket Hollow. These included animals who died of exposure to harsh weather; animals suffering with untreated injuries; animals being handled improperly; small, filthy enclosures; lack of access to clean water and food; food contaminated with vermin; the list went on and on.
And yet the USDA continued to renew Cricket Hollow’s Animal Welfare Act exhibitor license despite these documented violations. In fact the zoo was issued 11 violations by the agency the day its license was renewed. In 2015, USDA reissued the license again, despite the fact that according to the USDA’s own inspection reports, it had cited the facility for over 100 violations in the prior five years. Citations included inadequate staffing, unsanitary facilities, and poor veterinary care.
In 2014, the Animal Legal Defense Fund sued the USDA for its renewal of Cricket Hollow’s animal exhibitor license. The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia dismissed the case in 2016.
In October 2017, this dismissal was reversed by the the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, which ruled that the USDA cannot “arbitrarily and capriciously” renew an exhibitor license to a roadside zoo it knows is in violation of the Animal Welfare Act. Our lawsuit was remanded to the District Court.
Shortly after this decision, in December 2017, the USDA revoked Cricket Hollow’s exhibitor license and issued a $10,000 fine against roadside zoo owners Pamela and Thomas Sellner. In the decision to revoke the license, Administrative Law Judge Channing D. Strother noted it was inconsistent with the Animal Welfare Act to allow licensees with “chronic violations to continue to operate without sanctions.”
As of July 2018, Cricket Hollow’s appeal of the USDA’s license revocation is on appeal. Our lawsuit against the USDA for issuing the license also remains pending.
The Animal Legal Defense Fund has successfully filed several lawsuits against and involving the Cricket Hollow Animal Park — formerly known as the Cricket Hollow Zoo — a roadside zoo in Manchester, Iowa. Please see cases (below) for more about the other lawsuits.
Recent News
-
Tentative Settlement Reached in Texas Endangered Species Act Lawsuit
The Animal Legal Defense Fund and National Foundation for Rescued Animals, an animal exhibitor doing business as Tiger Creek Animal Sanctuary, have tentatively reached a settlement, pending the dismissal of the Endangered Species Act lawsuit filed in March 2022.February 28, 2024 Press Release -
Animal Legal Defense Fund Urges USDA to Revoke AWA License from Convicted Wildlife Trafficker
The Animal Legal Defense Fund submitted a complaint urging the USDA APHIS to investigate and revoke the AWA exhibitor license for Jason Clay.February 27, 2024 Press Release -
Legal Petition Urges USDA to Adopt Comprehensive Regulatory Framework for Wildlife Services Program
The Animal Legal Defense Fund, as part of a coalition, submitted a petition for rulemaking to the USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service urging Wildlife Services to phase out lethal control of wild animals, including prohibiting specific practices such as neck snares, M-44 cyanide bombs, lead bullets, and more.November 21, 2023 Press Release
Related Cases
-
Challenging Cricket Hollow Zoo’s Care of Endangered Species (2014)
Animal Legal Defense Fund v Tom and Pamela Sellner
-
Challenging Cricket Hollow Zoos Treatment of Endangered Lions (2016)
Animal Legal Defense Fund v Tom and Pamela Sellner
-
Urging USDA to Revoke AWA Exhibitor License from Jason Clay (2024)
Complaint to USDA submitted on February 27, 2024
Looking for case and legal resources? View Resources
See MoreDonate to Protect Animals
Help animals win the legal protections they so desperately need and deserve, and ensure they have an advocate in courtrooms and legislatures across the country.