Lawsuit Against California Pig Farm Dropped as Company Announces End to Abusive Breeding Practices

Posted on March 5, 2008

Animal Legal Defense Fund Dismisses Lawsuit Arguing that Corcpork,
Inc. Violated Anti-Cruelty Laws by Keeping Pigs in Illegal Intensive
Confinement Conditions

A row of gestation cratesSanta Rosa, Ca.
The Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF), East Bay Animal Advocates, and
three Bay Area residents today dismissed their lawsuit, originally
filed in Sonoma County Superior Court, against Corcpork, Inc.,
California’s largest industrial pig farming operation, after the
facility agreed to stop the abusive practice of confining thousands of
female pigs in crates so tiny that they cannot turn around or even
scratch. The sows–all of them either pregnant or nursing–must lie on
hard concrete floors, in their own excrement, without the ability to
take even a single step. This confinement violates state anti-cruelty
laws, which require that animals be provided with adequate exercise
area. The settlement agreement states that "The elimination of breeding
at the Corcoran farm is presently taking place and will be completed on
or before May 31, 2008."

ALDF’s lawsuit alleged that Tulare County’s Corcpork, Inc. kept its
roughly 9,000 pregnant and nursing pigs in violation of Section 597t of
the California Penal Code, which requires that "every person who keeps
an animal confined in an enclosed area shall provide [him or her] with
an adequate exercise area." At Corcpork, the sows spent virtually their
entire lives crammed into stalls that were often so small that the
sows’ bodies were forced into the bars at either end. Confined in these
restrictive "gestation crates" (used during pregnancy) and "farrowing
crates" (used during nursing), these highly sensitive animals were
forced to endure a constant cycle of pregnancy followed almost
immediately after giving birth by impregnation, until their bodies
finally gave out.

Corcpork’s decision to end its abusive breeding operation, which,
according to terms described in the dismissal, is not being relocated
elsewhere, is part of a growing trend in the pig farming industry,
driven by consumer demand and by lawsuits, like ALDF v. Corcpork,
taking large "factory farms" to task for violating laws designed to
protect both animals and consumers. In January 2007, Virginia-based
Smithfield Foods, the largest pork producer in the world, announced
that it would phase out gestation stalls in all of its operations over
the next ten years. Days later, Maple Leaf Foods, the largest pork
producer in Canada, announced a similar ten-year phase out. Those
decisions came in the wake of ballot initiatives in Florida and Arizona
that banned the use of gestation crates in those states. A coalition of
animal groups called Californians for Humane Farms
has just completed gathering hundreds of thousands of signatures to get
a similar initiative on the California ballot in 2008. Smithfield Foods
Vice President of Environmental and Corporate Affairs Dennis Treacy was
quoted as saying the company’s decision to phase out crates was based
on "the desires of customers, who for whatever reason, have asked us to
look at different ways to do things."

"The writing is on the wall for industrial farming operations like
Corcpork, who continue to subject animals to intensive confinement,
despite increased consumer call for more humane farming methods," says
ALDF Executive Director Stephen Wells. "We’re delighted to be able to
dismiss this lawsuit, knowing that thousands of intelligent, sensitive
pigs will no longer suffer in conditions so cruel that they are
unimaginable–and unacceptable–to the growing number of compassionate
consumers who care about the welfare of farmed animals."

A copy of the settlement agreement is available upon request. For more information, visit
The Animal Legal Defense Fund was founded in 1979 with the unique
mission of protecting the lives and advancing interests of animals
through the legal system. The plaintiffs were represented by Bruce
Wagman and the San Francisco office of Schiff Hardin, and by Evans and
Page, San Francisco.

Be a Partner in Protection!

Donate monthly to help animals.

or make a one-time gift »

ALDF's Online Store

Help fund our lifesaving work!


Stay Connected

Sign up for Action Alerts.

Join Us

Follow ALDF on these networks:

Stay Connected

Sign up for Action Alerts.