Legally Brief: Legal Victories for Animals in 2014

Posted by Stephen Wells, ALDF Executive Director on December 19, 2014

Legally Brief

The Animal Legal Defense Fund has helped to achieve victories in some tough legal battles for animals this year, which wouldn’t have been possible without our members and supporters. For example, South Dakota became the 50th state to make the most egregious acts of animal cruelty a felony—as ALDF’s just-released 2014 State Rankings Report demonstrates. ALDF also submitted “friend of the court” briefs in support of West Hollywood’s first-in-the-nation ban on the sale of products made from animal fur and the Country of Origin Labeling (COOL) law for meat and poultry products. We received thousands of hours of pro bono legal assistance from top law firms and we added our 201st student ALDF chapter at the University of Mississippi School of Law, and co-hosted another sold-out Animal Law Conference at Lewis & Clark Law School, in Portland, Oregon. In other great news for animals:

Animals Used as Food


  • ALDF’s pending lawsuits challenging existing ag gag laws have taken positive turns as they move through the courts in Utah and Idaho. These groundbreaking lawsuits challenge the formidable animal agriculture industry’s attempts to criminalize whistle-blowers who document animal cruelty on factory farms. Making landmark progress, ALDF and a broad coalition are challenging these statutes for violating the U.S. Constitution, and things are looking good in both cases.
  • The Supreme Court allowed the California foie gras ban to stand, leaving intact the 9th Circuit Court’s ruling that states have the right to enact stricter animal welfare protections and product bans, even if those prohibitions impact interstate commerce.
  • ALDF won a victory for hens and consumers by settling with Bay Area egg producer Judy’s Family Farm Organic Eggs. As a result of the settlement, the producer had to change its advertising and pay $44,000 (split equally between the Sonoma Humane Society, Public Justice Foundation, and Consumer Action). More information about the settlement can be found here.
  • After ALDF documented worker safety violations, showing trainers in the water with a captive orca named Lolita, OSHA fined the Miami Seaquarium $7,000 as a result of an ALDF complaint.

Wildlife & Killing Contests

Animals in Shelters


  • North Carolina agreed to stop gassing dogs and cats in shelters in the wake of an ALDF rulemaking petition. This controversial method of destroying animals is already outlawed in numerous states, because animals are often crammed in small enclosures in which they sense the coming gas, panic together, and take an unnecessarily long time to die.

Animals & Transportation

Throughout the year, but especially during the holiday season, we reflect on our shared commitment to not only the animals we’ve saved, but also to those we have yet to save. As long as there are animals suffering, they need ALDF as their legal advocate, and that’s where you come in. As a proud supporter and member of ALDF, you make our work for animals possible. Right now you can double your impact for animals with a tax-deductible year-end contribution to our fight to win the case against animal cruelty. Please help us make ALDF even stronger in 2015!

Thank you all, and happy holidays!

6 thoughts on “Legally Brief: Legal Victories for Animals in 2014

  1. Sonya Boyd says:

    thank you so much! I am a huge animal advocate & lover & appreciate all that you have done & will do for animals in the future.

  2. Janet in Cambridge MA says:

    Keep on keepin’ on!!!

  3. It is hopeful to see the accomplishments, thank you for all these efforts. The underlying concept of animals as mere property must be challenged wherever possible.

  4. Thank you for helping end gassing in NC now KY PLEASE .
    Also your push for an animal shelter in Paintsville KY was good but still no shelter just talk.

  5. James Talbert says:

    I love what you’re doing here! Thanks to everyone who puts in work on behalf of the voiceless.

  6. Franco Ferrua says:

    Thanks for your help for these wonderful beings. Why is California usually at the forefront of these issues and many other compassionate matters? Any ideas?

    I love many areas of California, for various reasons, but am still perplexed how advanced they are in many ways. Please, no California bashing.

Be a Partner in Protection!

Donate monthly to help animals.

or make a one-time gift »

ALDF's Online Store

Help fund our lifesaving work!


Stay Connected

Sign up for Action Alerts.

Join Us

Follow ALDF on these networks:

Stay Connected

Sign up for Action Alerts.